Sweet Rewards For Sharing Sweetness
Black and White Cookies in Staten Island
Fresh, Local & Lovingly New York
When Staten Island craves something sweet, authentic, and full of New York tradition, there’s one bakery that delivers it perfectly every time Golden Star Bakery.
Our Black and White Cookies in Staten Island are baked fresh daily with a soft, cake-like base, hand-glazed in smooth vanilla and rich chocolate, and delivered straight to your door. Whether you’re near the Staten Island Ferry, strolling through Tottenville, or meeting friends in Great Kills, every bite brings the true flavor of New York’s most iconic cookie.
A Classic NYC Cookie With a Staten Island Touch
Staten Island knows good baking. From neighborhood delis to weekend coffee shops, residents appreciate flavor that’s honest and comforting and that’s exactly what we bake.
At Golden Star Bakery, our Black and White Cookies are made from scratch every morning using locally sourced ingredients. The soft vanilla-cake texture and glossy half-chocolate, half-vanilla icing embody everything that makes New York famous for dessert.
It’s simple. It’s elegant. It’s a cookie that connects generations and now, it’s closer than ever for Staten Island families to enjoy.
Fat Free Chocolate Brownies
Fat-Free Brownies are made with premium quality ingredients, carefully selected to provide you with a delightful and nutritious experience. Every bite is an explosion of rich, velvety chocolate goodness that will leave you wanting more! Enjoy the rich taste of chocolatey goodness while knowing you're making a smart, health-conscious choice. Try Fat-Free Brownies today and embark on a delicious journey that satisfies your chocolate cravings while keeping you on track towards your wellness goals. Each Fat-Free Brownie is individually wrapped for freshness, only 80 calories per serving and seriously soft and yummy. No need to sacrifice flavor for your health goals!
Fat-Free Cinnamon Goldies
Discover a guilt-free delight with Fat-Free Cinnamon Goldies! Indulge in the warm embrace of aromatic cinnamon combined with the golden crispiness of these delectable cookies. These Fat-Free Cinnamon Goldies offer a delectable way to satisfy your cravings without compromising on flavor. They are deliciously frosted, individually wrapped for freshness, only 107 calories per serving size and packed with 3 grams of fiber to support body's wellbeing. No need to sacrifice flavor for your health goals!
Fat-Free Celebration Cookies
Fat Free Celebration Cookie is the perfect solution for those who want to indulge in a sweet treat without the added calories. Bursting with tangy lemon flavor and covered in colorful sprinkles, these cookies are a festive addition to any occasion. Each Celebration Cookie is only 75 calories per serving and seriously soft and yummy. No need to sacrifice flavor for your health goals! Indulge in guilt-free snacking now!
Fat-Free Pink & White Cookies
Fat-Free Pink & White Cookie is the ultimate treat that not only melts in your mouth but also fuels your body with nourishing goodness. With its reduced calorie count and fat-free recipe, it's the perfect guilt-free indulgence for those mindful of their waistlines and overall well-being. The rich, velvety white and pink frosting perfectly complements the wholesome cookie base, making it a delightful treat for all taste buds. Each cookie is 80 calories per serving and individually wrapped, making it the perfect convenient snack to take on the go, share with friends, or enjoy whenever you need a pick-me-up.
Fat-Free Black & White Cookies
Black and White Fat-Free Cookie is the ultimate treat that not only melts in your mouth but also fuels your body with nourishing goodness. With its reduced calorie count and fat-free recipe, it's the perfect guilt-free indulgence for those mindful of their waistlines and overall well-being. The rich, velvety white and dark chocolate frosting perfectly complements the wholesome cookie base, making it a delightful treat for all taste buds. Each cookie is 80 calories per serving and individually wrapped, making it the perfect convenient snack to take on the go, share with friends, or enjoy whenever you need a pick-me-up.
Why Staten Island Chooses Golden Star Bakery
Our customers across St. George, Huguenot, and Annadale love our cookies because they’re not just tasty they’re made with care, quality, and community in mind.
Why We’re Staten Island’s Favorite:
- Fresh Daily Bakes – never frozen, always soft and flavorful.
- Local Delivery – from Ferry Terminal to Tottenville.
- Classic and Low-Sugar Options – same flavor, fewer calories.
- Eco-Friendly Packaging – because we care about our island.
- Perfect for Gifting – beautiful boxes for birthdays, holidays, and family events.
We’re more than a bakery we’re a part of the community. Our cookies bring neighbors together, from weekend picnics to school celebrations, and every smile in between.
Order Black and White Cookies Online – Staten Island Delivery
You don’t have to take the ferry to Manhattan to enjoy New York’s favorite cookies Golden Star Bakery ships them right here in Staten Island.
Available Varieties
- Classic Black and White Cookies – the timeless New York original.
- Sugar-Free and Low-Carb Cookies – for a guilt-free treat.
- Traditional Italian Cookies – perfect for sharing and events
We ship fresh daily across:
St. George, Great Kills, Tottenville, Annadale, Huguenot, New Dorp, and Eltingville.
Each order arrives bakery-fresh soft, aromatic, and sealed with flavor.
Whether it’s a small family order or a bulk celebration, your cookies come with the same care and quality every time.
Order now and bring home the Staten Island sweetness everyone’s talking about.
Our Neighborhoods & Local Love
Every borough has its own identity and Staten Island’s heart lies in its people.
We’re proud to bake for these amazing communities:
- St. George – Perfect for commuters who crave a New York classic after the ferry ride.
- Tottenville – Family gatherings and neighborhood get-togethers love our cookie boxes.
- Great Kills – Cafés and small shops featuring local desserts partner with us for quality.
- Annadale & Huguenot – Celebrations, birthdays, and events made sweeter with Golden Star cookies.
- New Dorp – Business offices ordering fresh cookie trays for meetings and clients.
Wherever you are on the island, our ovens are never too far away.
How We Bake the Perfect Staten Island Cookie
Our recipe is built on trust the kind only experience can deliver.
- Soft Cake-Like Base: Our dough is light and fluffy, baked for texture not crunch.
- Premium Icing: Smooth, glossy, and flavorful; never waxy or overly sweet.
- Balanced Flavors: Perfect harmony between chocolate and vanilla.
- Small Batch Production: Every tray baked fresh for consistent quality.
- Local Ingredients: Supporting nearby suppliers and farms whenever possible.
The result? A cookie that captures what Staten Island is all about community, craftsmanship, and care.
Staten Island Stories That Make Us Proud
“I grew up eating Black and White Cookies from Manhattan bakeries, and now I can get the same quality right here in Staten Island. Golden Star Bakery nailed it!”
“We ordered the fat free ones for my dad’s birthday he couldn’t believe they were diet-friendly. Best cookies on the island!”
We love hearing from our Staten Island family because every review, every repeat order, every smile is what keeps us baking.
Cookies Made for Every Moment
From weekday lunches to weekend family dinners, our Staten Island Black and White Cookies fit every occasion.
- Enjoy them with coffee on the porch.
- Gift them to friends across the island.
- Serve them at weddings, baby showers, or holidays.
And with our low-fat range, you can share them freely with everyone in the family.
Because great taste shouldn’t need a trip to Manhattan. it should live right here in Staten Island.
Taste New York’s Favorite Cookie Without Leaving the Island
You’ve seen them in Manhattan bakeries, tasted them at city cafés now they’re yours, baked fresher and delivered faster.
Golden Star Bakery brings the city’s most beloved cookie to Staten Island, one delivery at a time.
Order today and enjoy:
- Authentic New York Black and White Cookies
- Same-day Staten Island delivery
- Beautiful gift boxes and bulk orders
- The taste of New York tradition, locally baked
Proudly Serving St. George, Tottenville, Great Kills, Annadale, and beyond.
What Our Customers Say
Discover the smiles at Golden Star Bakery through reviews from our wonderful customers in NY. Here are snippets of their thoughts, sharing the love for our treats, service, and the overall experience –
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I buy black and white cookies in Staten Island?
You can order fresh Black and White Cookies in Staten Island directly from Golden Star Bakery baked every morning and delivered island-wide.
Who makes the best black and white cookies near me in Staten Island?
Locals say Golden Star Bakery makes the best black and white cookies soft, cake-like, perfectly glazed, and authentically New York.
Do you deliver cookies across all Staten Island neighborhoods?
Yes! We deliver daily to St. George, Great Kills, Tottenville, Annadale, Huguenot, New Dorp, and Eltingville, ensuring every order arrives fresh.
Are your cookies available in sugar-free or low-fat options?
Yes, every batch is baked fresh each morning using premium ingredients, never frozen, and always hand-glazed for that authentic texture and taste.
Do you deliver to St. George and Tottenville?
Yes, Golden Star Bakery delivers daily to St. George and Tottenville, offering the same fresh, hand-baked cookies we’re known for in Manhattan.
Can I get cookies delivered to Great Kills or Annadale?
Definitely! We serve Great Kills, Annadale, and Huguenot, delivering fresh black and white cookies for homes, cafés, and local events.
Do you deliver to New Dorp and Eltingville?
Yes, we provide fast, same-day delivery to New Dorp, Eltingville, and nearby neighborhoods, ensuring every cookie arrives bakery-fresh.
What’s the best bakery for black and white cookies near me in Staten Island?
Search “black and white cookies near me in Staten Island” and you’ll find Golden Star Bakery — Staten Island’s favorite destination for authentic NYC cookies.
Can I order cookies for parties or corporate events?
Absolutely. We specialize in bulk orders and celebration boxes, ideal for birthdays, offices, weddings, and community gatherings across Staten Island.
Do you offer same-day or weekend delivery?
Yes, we offer same-day and weekend deliveries across Staten Island so your cookies are always fresh and on time.
Are your cookies made locally on Staten Island?
Yes. our cookies are baked fresh in New York and delivered locally to Staten Island with the same quality and flavor that defines a true NYC bakery.
